- What is imposter syndrome?
- Is imposter syndrome more prevalent now?
- The prevalence of imposter syndrome may be partially due to circumstance
- How do you land a freelance gig without actual experience?
- Am I an imposter, or can I really do this?
- Suffering from imposter syndrome feels trendy
- What’s the difference between self-doubt and imposter syndrome?
- Ever heard of these folks?
- Speaking of Mike Tyson…
- So, yes, I suffer from imposter syndrome
Have you heard of imposter syndrome? If you haven’t, you likely haven’t been online—ever. It seems like I see the term almost daily. It’s one of those things—once I started noticing it, I started seeing it everywhere. It’s kind of like the awkward English I find in Korea. I see new examples every time I leave my neighborhood. I’ve snapped pics of everything on my regular routes—trust me.
What is imposter syndrome?
The Freedictionary.com defines imposter syndrome as:
Impostor syndrome (also known as impostor phenomenon, impostorism, fraud syndrome or the impostor experience) is a psychological pattern in which an individual doubts their skills, talents or accomplishments and has a persistent internalized fear of being exposed as a “fraud.” Despite external evidence of their competence, those experiencing this phenomenon remain convinced that they are frauds, and do not deserve all they have achieved. Individuals with impostorism incorrectly attribute their success to luck, or interpret it as a result of deceiving others into thinking they are more intelligent than they perceive themselves to be. While early research focused on the prevalence among high-achieving women, impostor syndrome has been recognized to affect both men and women equally.
It goes on to mention that the term was introduced in 1978 by Dr. Pauline R. Clance and Dr. Suzanne A. Imes. Their study was based on interviews with 150 high-achieving women. Despite arguable success in their respective fields, these women struggled to acknowledge their accomplishments. They felt like “frauds” or “imposters.”
Since then, this phenomenon has continued to be studied. The above link lists several famous people who’ve reported suffering from imposter syndrome. Most of those people would be considered accomplished in their respective fields.
Is imposter syndrome more prevalent now?
This could just be me, but I don’t remember hearing this term until about three years ago. It was around the time I switched careers from teaching to freelance copywriting. While learning about my new career, I saw lots of people suffering from imposter syndrome. I mean lots.
I decided to ask one of my new best friends about this. ChatGPT gave me several possibilities as to why imposter syndrome seems more common now.
I think the most important reason it gave me was the rise of social media. This makes perfect sense to me. While social media has its uses, it’s easy to get sucked into the pitfall of comparing yourself to everyone else. That partially explains why I saw so many references to imposter syndrome while learning about copywriting and proofreading.
When you start learning about copywriting and proofreading, you’ll come across successful copywriters and proofreaders. Well, copywriters and proofreaders who are more successful than you! As I’ve mentioned before, I noticed that many successful copywriters offer some info for free. But it’s their paid courses that promise to have you making six figures in no time.
The prevalence of imposter syndrome may be partially due to circumstance
This relates to another point ChatGPT gave me—the rise of the gig economy and freelancing. Combine this with another reason that resonated with me—remote work and isolation. Now you have the perfect storm.
When I made my career change, we were in the middle of the COVID-19 pandemic. People were working from home, and some, like myself, had lost their jobs and were trying to figure out new paths. Since remote work was at its peak, more folks like myself were making a go of it as freelancers.
That’s a unique thing about freelancing—qualifications are a murky thing. When I started out as an English copywriter and proofreader, I didn’t have any experience in the field. And that’s something I see all the time with people trying to make it as freelancers. They lack practical experience.
How do you land a freelance gig without actual experience?
I had related experience that I was convinced I could apply to my new career. I’d spent 20+ years teaching and correcting English. I have a Master’s degree in TESOL. I’ve been teaching, correcting, and assessing writing for more than two decades.
But the thing with a lot of freelance gigs is that you’ve got to prove yourself. That’s how I got my two most lucrative freelance gigs when I was starting out. For both of those gigs, I was given test tasks. There’s a lot of negativity surrounding unpaid test tasks, but as someone with no experience, I had no issue. When I applied for a proofreading job with the Korean Board of Audit and Inspection, I had to take an on-site test.
With one of those test tasks, the person evaluating my work gave me feedback on my initial submission. They said something like, “Your first attempt was decent, but I’m looking for someone who can take it to the next level. Can you do that? Can you tighten it up, trim all the fat, and make it pop?”
Am I an imposter, or can I really do this?
I gave it another go. Apparently, my best was good enough. That gig started at 4 hours/week and grew into more than 20 hours/week. I learned a lot from that gig in the year I had it. The person who hired me was very patient and was always keen to teach me something new.
I had a sample test task for the other long-term gig I got. That’s the one that I have now—3 ½ years later. Again, that started as a few hours a week doing some writing—but only after I passed the initial test. But the more I proved I could do what I claimed, my hours and responsibilities increased.
I got both of these gigs without sector experience. But I could also back up my claims. I claimed I could transfer the skills I’d been using for the past two decades to this new career—and I proved it.
Suffering from imposter syndrome feels trendy
I’m sure I’ll get flak for this, but hear me out. Let’s return to the world of social media. It’s pretty common for us to post about how tough our lives are to get sympathy from others. I try not to do it, but I’ve definitely been guilty a few times. I’ve previously posted about how I was struggling while working 50-hour weeks. I’m sure some folks would’ve killed for 10 of those hours. I complained, but I’d much rather have been working 50 hours a week than not having any work for five weeks.
But check out the comments where people claim to suffer from imposter syndrome. They’re packed with positive messages of encouragement. Commenters talk about how they used to feel like that, but now they’re successful. They encourage the poster not to give up and to just believe in themselves.
Don’t get me wrong, imposter syndrome is a real thing. I just don’t think everyone claiming to be suffering from it actually has it. I think they’re just experiencing some good old-fashioned self-doubt.
And imposter syndrome, real or perceived, is not limited to freelancers. I found an article in my work email about early childhood educators suffering from imposter syndrome. The people in this article are educational leaders and likely have years of experience. Are they really suffering from imposter syndrome? Or are they just experiencing some self-doubt? It doesn’t help that the article uses the terms interchangeably.
What’s the difference between self-doubt and imposter syndrome?
Let’s go back to the definition at the beginning of this post. It says those with imposter syndrome doubt their abilities “despite external evidence of their competence.” That’s the key point. A lot of people trying to establish themselves as new freelance copywriters likely don’t have much (if any) “evidence of their competence.” I have no idea how long one needs to be in a job to amass evidence of one’s competence. But I’m pretty sure it doesn’t occur immediately.
I’m sure everyone has experienced self-doubt at some point. It may or may not be related to your job. It would shock me if there were anyone who has never second-guessed themselves at least once.
In my last post, I wrote about my testing method in my EFL conversation classes. I was a teacher for over two decades and had a master’s degree. Yet I sometimes wondered if I was “qualified” to assess my students. Sometimes, my grades affected whether they got a scholarship or not. But I trusted in my ability, my studies, and my experience. I admitted to myself that I could grade a conversation or a written assignment slightly differently on different days. That is bound to happen when subjectivity is involved.
But I had the confidence that over a period of time, things would average out. And quite frankly, a little self-doubt perhaps isn’t a bad thing.
Ever heard of these folks?
Being nervous about your abilities and having a dash of self-doubt is probably quite healthy. Ever heard of
- Paul McCartney?
- Michael Jordan?
- Tom Brady?
They’ve all got something in common—in addition to being famous for being very good at what they do. They all got nervous before games/performances. Both Jordan and Brady have said something like, “If you don’t feel nervous, you don’t care about the game anymore—it’s time to stop.” Basically, if you’re not worried about failing, you’ve stopped caring.
It’s like when a new parent questions their parenting ability. We often tell them, “The fact that you’re questioning your ability means you care.” None of us is ever “ready” to become a parent. We may think we are—until the baby arrives. We simply do the best we can.
Who was it that said, “Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face?”
Speaking of Mike Tyson…
What happens when you don’t have self-doubt? When you believe in your ability to the point of overconfidence? It usually ends badly.
That’s what happened to Iron Mike when he faced Buster Douglas. Tyson was the overwhelming favorite. But his overconfidence in his invincibility led him to underestimate Douglas. Douglas knocked Tyson out in one of the biggest upsets in sports history. Tyson’s lack of preparation and overconfidence contributed to his loss.
As I wrote about in my last post, I had several students like that. I’m talking about students who’d lived abroad and spoke English quite well. They figured my class would be a breeze. But they missed classes, didn’t do assignments, and didn’t prepare for the tests. They were also the first students to email me, begging for higher grades. Confidence is good. Overconfidence rarely ends well.
So, yes, I suffer from imposter syndrome
I don’t have imposter syndrome when it comes to my work. I know I’m still early in my new career, but I also have three and a half more years of experience than I did when I started. I’ve had several long-term contracts. I have testimonials on my site from satisfied customers. Several have become repeat customers.
When I say I “suffer” from imposter syndrome, I’m talking about the deluge of posts on social media from people just starting out. You don’t have imposter syndrome. You have self-doubt. Welcome to the club. It ain’t exactly exclusive.
When I made this career change, it was partially due to job insecurity. Another teaching job meant my contract could end when the school no longer wanted me. I decided to bet on myself. My success or failure would ultimately depend on how hard I worked and how well I performed. I liked those odds. Clients weren’t guaranteed, but I had a better chance of being rewarded for hard work.
I’ve had my doubts along the way, but I’m still in my current position. I’ve taken on more responsibilities and learned to use more platforms than I ever anticipated. Being promoted to the team lead and having more responsibilities tells me I’m doing something right.
So, what do you think? Am I being too harsh on people? Am I being too insensitive? Or are most of these people simply suffering from a healthy dose of self-doubt? Let me know in the comments.
Subscribe to this blog or follow me on Instagram, Threads, Facebook, or LinkedIn for more content and updates.
